7  How NMR, MRS, and MRI Differ

7.1 In a nutshell

The physics is the same in all of them (nuclear magnetic resonance). What differs is “what you want to know” and “whether you use position information.”

What is measured Position information Main subjects In short
NMR (spectroscopy) Spectrum and relaxation times of the whole sample None Samples in test tubes (chemistry, biochemistry), tissue or blood taken from the body “Which molecules, in what state”
MRS (MR spectroscopy) Spectrum of a region inside the body Select one to a few regions Living body (brain, muscle, liver) “Which metabolites, at that location”
MRI (imaging) Signal intensity, T1, T2, etc. per pixel Per pixel Living body “Where, and how much”

7.2 The trade-off between spectra and images

  • To make an image, the signal must be split into many pixels using gradients → the signal per pixel becomes small
  • If you give up position and collect the signal from the whole region together, the signal is strong (high SNR), acquisition is short, and you can measure fine information (chemical shift, relaxation components)

In a study of skeletal muscle 23Na, the researchers deliberately gave up imaging and measured the whole calf as a single spectrum. With a 14-minute acquisition they measured total Na, TQF, T1 and T2 components, and more with high sensitivity, and detected rapid changes in extracellular fluid volume more sensitively than 1H T2 images (Gerhalter et al. 2017).

flowchart LR
  A["Discard position information<br/>(NMR / non-localized MRS)"] -- "Strong, fast signal;<br/>components finely separable" --> C["What state it is in"]
  B["Keep position information<br/>(MRI)"] -- "Distribution per pixel<br/>(signal per pixel is weak)" --> D["Where it is"]

7.3 Chemical shift and ppm

As in Chapter 5, even the same nucleus rotates at a slightly different frequency depending on the state of the surrounding electrons. Expressing this shift as a fraction of the scanner frequency, in ppm (parts per million), allows the same value to be compared across scanners with different field strengths.

\[ \delta \ [\text{ppm}] = \frac{f - f_{ref}}{f_{ref}} \times 10^6 \]

  • 1H MRS: water (4.7 ppm), fat (1.3 ppm, etc.), creatine (3.0 ppm), intra- and extramyocellular lipids in muscle (IMCL, EMCL), and others
  • 31P MRS: PCr (0 ppm), Pi, ATP (Chapter 6)

7.4 NMR outside the body

When tissue, blood, or urine taken from the body is measured with a high-field NMR spectrometer, the spectrum is separated far more finely than in vivo, and this is used for metabolomics, which quantifies many metabolites together. Measurements that are difficult in vivo also become possible, such as adding a shift reagent to separate intracellular and extracellular 23Na into distinct peaks.

7.5 Summary

  • NMR, MRS, and MRI share the same principle. They differ in how much position information they use
  • The more position information you give up, the stronger and faster the signal and the finer the information you can obtain
  • Chemical shift is expressed in ppm, so it can be compared even between scanners with different field strengths