9 Review Questions
Open “Answer” below each question to see the answer and explanation. Think it through yourself first before opening it.
9.1 Basic
Q1
Why is the resting heart rate (60–70 bpm) lower than the intrinsic heart rate (about 100 bpm)?
Because at rest vagal (parasympathetic) activity predominates and continuously suppresses the automaticity of the sinus node. When the vagus is blocked with atropine, the heart rate rises to near the intrinsic heart rate. (Chapter 2)
Q2
Name two molecular mechanisms by which the vagus nerve lowers the heart rate. Also explain why its effect is faster than that of the sympathetic nerves.
ACh binds to M2 receptors and activates Gi/o proteins.
- Gβγ directly opens GIRK channels (IK,ACh), hyperpolarizing the cell through K⁺ efflux
- Gαi inhibits adenylyl cyclase, lowering cAMP and suppressing If and the Ca²⁺ clock
The pathway in which Gβγ directly opens ion channels does not go through multi-step chemical reactions, and ACh is rapidly degraded by acetylcholinesterase, so the effect appears and disappears quickly (within one beat). The sympathetic nerves go through a multi-step pathway of cAMP production → phosphorylation by PKA, and NE is removed slowly, so they take several seconds to ten-plus seconds. (Chapter 2)
Q3
What is respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA)? Describe its main mechanism.
A physiological phenomenon in which heart rate rises (RR shortens) during inspiration and falls (RR lengthens) during expiration. The main mechanism is central gating, in which the medullary respiratory center suppresses the activity of cardiac vagal neurons in the nucleus ambiguus during inspiration. Added to this are reflexes from pulmonary stretch receptors and baroreflex effects due to changes in intrathoracic pressure. All of these are mediated by cardiac vagal activity, so RSA almost disappears with atropine. (Chapter 3)
Q4
Describe the difference in how SDNN and RMSSD are calculated, and state what each mainly reflects.
- SDNN: the standard deviation of NN intervals. Reflects fluctuations of all frequencies within the recording (total power) and depends on recording length
- RMSSD: the root mean square of differences between adjacent NN intervals. Captures fast beat-to-beat changes and mainly reflects cardiac vagal activity. Strongly correlated with HF power and SD1
(Chapter 5)
9.2 Applied
Q5
Name three problems with the interpretation that “the LF/HF ratio represents the balance between sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves”.
- LF has a large vagal contribution, and atropine also greatly reduces LF
- LF power does not correlate with direct measures of cardiac sympathetic activity, such as noradrenaline release into the heart. One view is that it rather reflects baroreflex function
- The sympathetic and vagal nerves are not in a simple tug-of-war; there are many situations in which both increase or decrease at the same time
- Merely slowing breathing moves the respiratory fluctuation into LF and raises LF/HF greatly
(Chapters 5 and 6; Chapter 8, Experiments A and D)
Q6
In what situations is “HRV” measured with a smartwatch (wrist PPG) unlikely to agree with HRV obtained from a chest ECG? Also state why.
Agreement is poor during body movement, standing, exercise, and when peripheral blood flow is low, e.g., in the cold.
What PPG gives you is pulse rate variability (PRV), which adds the fluctuation of the time from the ECG R wave until the pulse wave reaches the periphery (pre-ejection period + pulse transit time). This time changes beat to beat with respiration and blood pressure, so RMSSD and HF in particular tend to be overestimated. In addition, motion noise and low perfusion reduce the accuracy of detecting the pulse-wave fiducial point. (Chapter 4; Chapter 8, Experiment E)
Q7
A 5-minute recording contained 2 premature beats. If analyzed without correction, which is affected more, RMSSD or SDNN? Answer with your reasoning.
RMSSD is affected more. A premature beat creates a very large adjacent difference (“short RR → long compensatory pause”), and RMSSD squares and averages these differences. SDNN is based on deviations from the mean, and the values of the short and long beats themselves do not deviate extremely from the mean, so the effect is relatively small. (Chapter 4; Chapter 8, Experiment B)
Q8
Resting RMSSD fell from 40 ms to 30 ms before and after an intervention. Name four things to check before concluding that “vagal activity decreased”.
- Has the heart rate risen? (A rise in heart rate alone makes RR fluctuations look smaller)
- Have the respiratory rate and depth of breathing changed?
- Are the posture, time of day, recording length, and pre-measurement conditions (meals, caffeine, exercise, sleep) the same?
- Is the correction of abnormal beats and artifacts appropriate, and is there a difference in correction rate?
- Is the change within the range of day-to-day within-individual variation?
(Chapter 6)
9.3 Advanced
Q9
Explain the mechanism by which slow breathing at about 6 breaths per minute enlarges HRV. Also explain why HF power can decrease at that time.
Because the baroreflex loop has a delay, it has an intrinsic oscillation (the Mayer wave) at about 0.1 Hz (a period of about 10 s). When breathing is set to about 0.1 Hz, the respiratory fluctuations of heart rate and blood pressure resonate with the baroreflex oscillation, and the heart-rate fluctuation becomes very large.
At this time the respiratory fluctuation is at 0.1 Hz, i.e., in the LF band, so power in the HF band (0.15–0.4 Hz) actually decreases. Reading the decrease in HF as a decrease in vagal activity is wrong. (Chapter 3; Chapter 8, Experiment A)
Q10
You want to record HRV every morning with a wearable device and use it to adjust training intensity. Propose rules for measurement and interpretation.
- Measurement: measure every morning right after waking and urinating, in the same posture (e.g., supine), with the same device and the same recording length (e.g., 1–5 min). Alternatively, use the value during nighttime sleep. Avoid talking and moving
- Metric: use lnRMSSD, which is stable even in short recordings and relatively less affected by respiration
- Interpretation:
- Look at the 7-day moving average, not the value of a single day
- Determine your individual reference range (e.g., mean ± 0.5 SD) from several weeks of your own data, and reduce intensity when you fall below it
- Also record heart rate, sleep duration, subjective fatigue and well-being, and alcohol intake, and judge them in combination
- Do not compare with other people’s values or values from other devices
(Chapters 6 and 7)