3  Origins of the Fluctuations: Respiration, Baroreflex, Slower Rhythms

In Chapter 2 we saw that “the vagus and sympathetic nerves change the heart rate”. Then why does that nerve activity itself fluctuate? In this chapter we look at the main origins of the fluctuations that make up HRV, from the highest frequency down.

Band Frequency Period Main origin
HF (high frequency) 0.15–0.4 Hz 2.5–7 s Respiration (respiratory sinus arrhythmia)
LF (low frequency) 0.04–0.15 Hz 7–25 s Baroreflex (blood pressure fluctuations with a period of about 10 s)
VLF (very low frequency) 0.0033–0.04 Hz 25 s–5 min Thermoregulation, renin–angiotensin system, physical activity, etc. (much is unknown)
ULF (ultra low frequency) ≤ 0.0033 Hz 5 min or longer Circadian rhythm, activity and rest, etc. (assessed with 24-hour recordings)

(Band boundaries according to Task Force 1996)

3.1 Respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA)

The phenomenon in which heart rate rises (RR shortens) during inspiration and falls (RR lengthens) during expiration is called respiratory sinus arrhythmia (RSA). Despite the name “arrhythmia”, it is a normal property of a healthy heart: it is larger in younger people and becomes smaller with aging and disease.

3.1.1 Mechanism

RSA arises from several overlapping mechanisms.

flowchart TB
  subgraph Central["① Central (main)"]
    RG["Respiratory rhythm generation in the medulla<br/>(preBötzinger complex)"] -->|"inhibited during inspiration"| NA["Cardiac vagal neurons<br/>in the nucleus ambiguus"]
  end
  subgraph Reflex["② Reflex"]
    Lung["Pulmonary stretch receptors<br/>(stretched during inspiration)"] -->|"vagal afferents"| NA
    Baro["Intrathoracic pressure↓ during inspiration<br/>→ changes in venous return and stroke volume<br/>→ baroreceptors"] --> NA
  end
  NA -->|"Inspiration: vagal activity↓<br/>Expiration: vagal activity↑"| SA["Sinus node"]
  SA --> HR["Inspiration: RR↓ (heart rate↑)<br/>Expiration: RR↑ (heart rate↓)"]

  1. Central gating: the respiratory center in the medulla suppresses the activity of cardiac vagal neurons with each inspiration. Thought to be the main cause of RSA
  2. Pulmonary stretch receptors: when the lungs inflate during inspiration, this information is conveyed via vagal afferents and suppresses the cardiac vagus
  3. Influence via the baroreflex: changes in intrathoracic pressure with breathing cause blood pressure to fluctuate, and the heart rate changes via the baroreflex

All of these pathways ultimately change cardiac vagal activity in synchrony with respiration, so the magnitude of RSA (HF power, RMSSD) is used as an index of cardiac vagal activity. When the vagus is blocked with atropine, RSA almost disappears.

3.1.2 Does RSA have a purpose?

One hypothesis for the physiological significance of RSA is improving the efficiency of pulmonary gas exchange (Hayano et al. 1996). The idea is that heart rate is raised to increase blood flow during inspiration, when the lungs contain more air, and lowered during expiration to reduce wasted beats.

NoteThe magnitude of RSA changes with how you breathe

The magnitude of RSA depends strongly not only on vagal activity but also on respiratory rate and tidal volume.

  • Slow, deep breathing → RSA becomes larger
  • Fast, shallow breathing → RSA becomes smaller

Therefore it is dangerous to read the size of HF in measurements without controlled breathing directly as “the size of vagal activity” (Chapter 6).

3.2 The baroreflex and the ~10-second fluctuation

Blood pressure has a fluctuation with a period of about 10 seconds (around 0.1 Hz), called the Mayer wave. Its main cause is thought to be resonance due to the delay in the baroreflex loop.

flowchart LR
  BP["Blood pressure↑"] --> BR["Baroreceptors in the<br/>carotid sinus and aortic arch"]
  BR --> NTS["Nucleus of the solitary tract (NTS)"]
  NTS -->|"fast"| Vag["Vagus↑<br/>→ heart rate↓"]
  NTS -->|"slow (seconds)"| Sym["Sympathetic (vascular)↓<br/>→ vasodilation"]
  Vag --> BP2["Blood pressure↓"]
  Sym --> BP2
  BP2 -.->|"delayed correction in the opposite direction<br/>→ overshoot → oscillation with ~10 s period"| BP

  • When baroreceptors sense a rise in blood pressure, they lower the heart rate via the vagus and dilate blood vessels via the sympathetic nerves, lowering blood pressure
  • The vascular sympathetic pathway has a delay of several seconds, so the correction overshoots in the opposite direction and an oscillation arises
  • This blood pressure fluctuation is also transmitted to the heart rate via the baroreflex → HRV in the LF band

3.2.1 Resonance-frequency breathing

When you breathe slowly at about 6 breaths per minute (0.1 Hz), the respiratory fluctuation (RSA) and the intrinsic oscillation of the baroreflex (about 0.1 Hz) resonate, and the heart-rate fluctuation becomes very large. This is exploited by HRV biofeedback (resonance-frequency breathing; Lehrer, Vaschillo) (Chapter 7).

TipCheck it in Chapter 8

In the hands-on, you will see that lowering the respiratory rate from 15 to 6 breaths/min moves the respiratory fluctuation from the HF band to the LF band, greatly changing the LF/HF ratio. Reading this as “LF/HF rose = sympathetic dominance” would lead to a completely wrong conclusion.

3.3 Slower fluctuations (VLF, ULF)

  • VLF: thermoregulation (changes in skin blood flow), the renin–angiotensin system, changes in physical activity, etc. are thought to be involved, but its physiological origin is not well understood. On the other hand, VLF power in 24-hour recordings has been reported to be strongly associated with prognosis after myocardial infarction
  • ULF: reflects the circadian rhythm (heart rate falls and HRV rises at night) and patterns of activity and sleep. Can be assessed only in 24-hour recordings

In short recordings of about 5 minutes, VLF cannot be assessed accurately and ULF cannot be assessed at all.

3.4 Summary

  • HF (0.15–0.4 Hz): respiratory sinus arrhythmia. Central gating + reflexes. Vagal in origin, but strongly dependent on how one breathes
  • LF (0.04–0.15 Hz): mainly the ~10-second oscillation of the baroreflex loop. Both vagal and sympathetic nerves are involved
  • VLF, ULF: thermoregulation, hormones, circadian rhythm, etc. Much about their origin is unknown
  • Breathing at about 6 breaths/min makes RSA and the baroreflex resonate, enlarging HRV