flowchart LR A["Ageing"] --> B["Lower-body subcutaneous fat↓<br/>Abdominal/visceral fat↑"] A --> C["Senescence-like changes and<br/>abnormal differentiation<br/>of preadipocytes"] A --> D["Atrophy and fibrosis<br/>of subcutaneous fat"] C --> E["Reduced capacity to<br/>store fat safely"] D --> E E --> F["Ectopic fat in liver,<br/>muscle, heart, etc.↑"]
5 Differences by Sex, Age and Ethnicity
The “allocation” between visceral and subcutaneous fat differs greatly between people. Fat distribution varies with sex, genetic background, disease, drugs and hormones, development and ageing (Tchkonia et al. 2013).
5.1 Sex differences: upper-body vs lower-body type
| Upper-body type (more common in men) | Lower-body type (more common in women) | |
|---|---|---|
| Names | android, truncal | gynoid, peripheral |
| Where fat accumulates | Abdomen (visceral and abdominal subcutaneous fat) | Gluteal and femoral subcutaneous fat |
| Metabolic risk | Independent risk | Protective |
(Classification and risk framing follow Lee et al. (2013). See also Wajchenberg (2000) for the biology of sex differences.)
5.1.1 Menopause and visceral fat
In a study that followed 156 premenopausal women for 4 years with annual CT and DXA (Lovejoy et al. 2008), it was reported that
- subcutaneous fat increased with age in everyone, but visceral fat increased significantly only in women who transitioned to menopause
- in the group that transitioned to menopause, plasma estradiol fell, and sleeping energy expenditure and fat oxidation also declined
That is, menopause itself is associated with increases in total body fat and visceral fat.
Visceral fat is also said to have many androgen receptors (Chapter 3) (Ibrahim 2010).
5.2 Ageing
- With ageing, a preferential increase in abdominal, especially visceral, fat and a decrease in lower-body subcutaneous fat is commonly reported, and this can occur independently of changes in body weight or waist circumference. Fat deposition in the heart, liver and skeletal muscle also increases (Kuk et al. 2009).
- A model has been proposed in which preadipocytes with ageing “mis-differentiate” into a pro-inflammatory, senescence-like state, impairing adipogenesis so that fatty acids can no longer be sequestered (Tchkonia et al. 2010).
- In older people, subcutaneous fat atrophies and becomes fibrotic, which is said to be closely linked to excessive ectopic fat accumulation and age-related diseases (菅波孝祥 2024).
5.3 Ethnicity: in Japanese people, risk rises “even with mild obesity”
- A WHO expert consultation concluded that in Asians the relationship between BMI, percent body fat and health risk differs from that in Europeans, and that a substantial proportion of people are at high risk of type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease at BMIs lower than the existing overweight cut-off (BMI 25). The BMI at which risk was observed varied from 22 to 25 across Asian populations (WHO Expert Consultation 2004).
- In Japan, BMI 25 or more is defined as obesity, on grounds including that the number of comorbidities exceeds one on average at BMI 25 (Examination Committee of Criteria for ’Obesity Disease’ in Japan and Japan Society for the Study of Obesity 2002). The same study reported that BMI correlated strongly with subcutaneous fat area (r = 0.82) but only weakly with visceral fat area (r = 0.54), and that among people with BMI 25 or more, BMI and visceral fat area were barely correlated (because of large individual variation in visceral fat) (Examination Committee of Criteria for ’Obesity Disease’ in Japan and Japan Society for the Study of Obesity 2002).
- It has been pointed out that Japanese people have a body fat distribution with less subcutaneous fat and relatively more ectopic fat, and have a comparable diabetes risk to Westerners at a lower BMI (菅波孝祥 2024).
The above results show that while BMI reflects subcutaneous fat well, visceral fat is hard to predict from BMI (Examination Committee of Criteria for ’Obesity Disease’ in Japan and Japan Society for the Study of Obesity 2002). Even at the same BMI, the amount of visceral fat can differ greatly from person to person.
5.4 Summary
- Upper-body (abdominal) fat is an independent risk; gluteofemoral fat is protective (Lee et al. 2013).
- At menopause, estradiol falls and visceral fat increases (Lovejoy et al. 2008).
- With ageing, lower-body subcutaneous fat decreases and visceral and ectopic fat increase (Kuk et al. 2009). Senescence-like changes in progenitor cells and atrophy/fibrosis of subcutaneous fat lie behind this (Tchkonia et al. 2010; 菅波孝祥 2024).
- In Asians, risk rises from a lower BMI (WHO Expert Consultation 2004), and Japan’s obesity criterion is BMI 25 or more. At BMI 25 or more, BMI and visceral fat are barely correlated (Examination Committee of Criteria for ’Obesity Disease’ in Japan and Japan Society for the Study of Obesity 2002).