3 Visceral vs Subcutaneous Fat: Histological Differences
Now for the main topic. Even though both are white adipose tissue, comparing visceral and subcutaneous fat reveals several differences.
3.1 Side-by-side comparison
Ibrahim’s (2010) review summarises visceral fat, compared with subcutaneous fat, as “more cellular, more vascular and innervated, containing more inflammatory and immune cells, with lower preadipocyte differentiation capacity and a higher proportion of large adipocytes,” and further states that it has “more glucocorticoid and androgen receptors” (Ibrahim 2010). The table below supplements this with individual studies.
| Item | Visceral fat (VAT) | Subcutaneous fat (SAT) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cellularity, vessels, nerves | More | Relatively fewer | Ibrahim (2010) |
| Macrophages | About twice as many in omental as in subcutaneous fat (severely obese people) | Fewer | Cancello et al. (2006) |
| Preadipocyte proliferation and lipid accumulation | Low in omental fat | High | Tchkonia et al. (2005) |
| Adipocyte size | Varies between reports (see the caution below) | (same as left) | Ibrahim (2010); Van Harmelen et al. (1998) |
| Venous drainage | Portal vein → liver | Systemic circulation | Ibrahim (2010) |
| Glucocorticoid and androgen receptors | More | Relatively fewer | Ibrahim (2010) |
| Activity of 11β-HSD1 (cortisol-reactivating enzyme) | High in omental stromal cells | Barely detectable | Bujalska et al. (1997) |
Below we look at the background of each item.
3.2 Density of cells, vessels and nerves
Visceral fat is said to be more cellular, with a richer supply of blood vessels and nerves, than subcutaneous fat (Ibrahim 2010). Differences between depots in innervation and blood flow are thought to influence the properties of each depot (Lee et al. 2013).
- More blood vessels → faster influx and efflux of fatty acids and hormones.
- More nerves → sympathetic signals for lipolysis reach the tissue more easily.
These are consistent with the property “visceral fat has active lipolysis,” which we will see in Chapter 4.
3.3 Immune cells and inflammation
- In a study that simultaneously sampled omental and abdominal subcutaneous fat from 55 severely obese people (BMI about 48), omental macrophages were about twice as numerous as subcutaneous ones. The abundance of omental macrophages correlated with fasting glucose, insulin, triglycerides and liver enzymes, and was also associated with hepatic fibrosis and inflammatory lesions (Cancello et al. 2006).
- The omentum contains lymphocyte aggregates called milky spots, which collect antigens and pathogens in the peritoneal cavity and mount immune responses; the omentum thus also has an aspect as a tissue of peritoneal immunity (Meza-Perez and Randall 2017).
Inflammation of visceral fat also attracts attention because the factors produced there can reach the liver via the portal vein (Cancello et al. 2006).
3.4 Preadipocytes and the “capacity to multiply”
A study that isolated and cultured preadipocytes from human abdominal subcutaneous, mesenteric and omental fat (Tchkonia et al. 2005) showed that
- abdominal subcutaneous progenitors accumulate lipid better than omental progenitors, express higher levels of transcription factors involved in adipocyte differentiation, and are less susceptible to TNF-α-induced cell death
- proliferative capacity (how many times they can divide) is high in subcutaneous and mesenteric fat and low in omental fat
- these differences persist in culture
In other words, note also that “visceral fat” is not monolithic: mesenteric and omental fat differ in their properties.
Furthermore, in subcutaneous and intra-abdominal fat from mice and humans, the expression of genes involved in embryonic development and body pattern formation differed by depot, and the differences persisted in culture (Gesta et al. 2006). This suggests that fat’s “memory of site” may derive from genetically programmed developmental differences.
In mice, it was shown that all six visceral fat depots receive a large contribution from Wt1-expressing cells (thought to be of mesothelial origin) in late gestation, whereas subcutaneous and brown fat do not arise from Wt1-expressing cells (Chau et al. 2014). How far the same holds in humans remains to be determined, but it is one basis for the idea that “visceral and subcutaneous fat may be different things from birth.”
3.5 Adipocyte size: a point on which reports differ
- In a comparison of 15 obese and 8 non-obese women, subcutaneous adipocytes were reported to be about 50% larger than omental adipocytes (Van Harmelen et al. 1998).
- On the other hand, Ibrahim’s (2010) review summarises visceral fat as having a higher proportion of large adipocytes (Ibrahim 2010).
Because size can vary with sex, degree of obesity, the subcutaneous site compared and the measurement method, it is safest to remember that one cannot simply say “the cells are larger/smaller because it is visceral fat.”
Note that in a study that separately examined omental and subcutaneous adipocyte size in 80 severely obese women, omental cell size was associated with blood lipids (apo B, LDL cholesterol, triglycerides), and subcutaneous cell size with insulin, glucose and insulin sensitivity, both independently of age, BMI and body fat mass (Hoffstedt et al. 2010). Even for the same “size,” the associated metabolic markers differ by site.
What matters more is, as we saw in Chapter 2, that large (hypertrophic) adipocytes predict the onset of diabetes independently of body fat mass (Weyer et al. 2000).
3.6 Receptors and the local hormonal environment
- Visceral fat is said to have more glucocorticoid and androgen receptors (Ibrahim 2010).
- In a study culturing omental and subcutaneous adipose stromal cells obtained at surgery, the activity of 11β-HSD1, which converts inactive cortisone into active cortisol, was high in omental cells and barely detectable in subcutaneous cells. This activity was further increased by cortisol and insulin (Bujalska et al. 1997).
Glucocorticoids regulate adipose tissue differentiation, function and distribution, and in excess cause central obesity (Bujalska et al. 1997). Because the omentum can generate cortisol locally, Bujalska and colleagues described central obesity as “Cushing’s disease of the omentum” (Bujalska et al. 1997).
3.7 Summary
- Visceral fat is rich in cells, vessels, nerves and immune cells (Ibrahim 2010). In the omentum of severely obese people, macrophages are about twice as numerous as in subcutaneous fat (Cancello et al. 2006).
- Subcutaneous progenitors accumulate lipid better and proliferate more than omental ones; mesenteric fat, however, is closer to subcutaneous fat (Tchkonia et al. 2005).
- Differences between depots may be cell-autonomous and trace back to developmental origins (Gesta et al. 2006; Chau et al. 2014).
- Comparisons of adipocyte size differ between reports (Ibrahim 2010; Van Harmelen et al. 1998).
- Visceral fat has a local environment prone to glucocorticoid action (Ibrahim 2010; Bujalska et al. 1997).